In the USA a third of all land, about 840 million acres, is publicly owned. The government agencies that administer and manage federal public lands include the National Park Service (84 million acres), the Bureau of Land Management (248 million acres), the US Forest Service (193 million acres), the US Fish and Wildlife Service (95 million acres), and State and Local Government (199 Million acres) [1]
That’s a lot of land. Most of it is open to the public, and anyone can visit it. However, it is generally underutilized. About 75% of Americans never use public lands, [2] especially those lands located outside urban areas. In states where there is more public land, accessing it is easier. From where I live in Idaho, I can drive to land managed by the BLM in about 10 minutes.
In some places, there are restrictions and user fees. They help protect the land from damage caused by overuse and provide funds to help pay the cost of managing the land.
Who owns American public lands? This is where it gets muddy, (if you will pardon the play on words.) Some sources indicate that the “Property Clause” (Article 4, Section 3, Clause 2) of the US Constitution gives Congress the power to buy, sell, and regulate the use of federal lands. [3] I am not a Constitutional Lawyer, but I don’t see anything there about ownership. Other sources say that the public lands belong to the people. [4] According to the Public Lands Alliance, federal lands are owned by the people and managed by various government agencies. Their website provides an excellent visual description (map) of the location of US public lands, and an organizational chart that shows the various federal agencies responsible for managing federal public lands. [5]
It is important to understand that public lands managed by our state and local governments are subject to different use and management rules and regulations. For instance, state trust lands are commonly leased to provide funds for schools and universities. City parks may be subject to curfews for public safety, and county parks and recreation areas are often subject to user fees.
The federal government tries to regulate the public lands for multiple uses; like agriculture, grazing, logging, mining, and recreation, to name a few. Leases and fees are charged to help fund the management of federal public lands.
This has led to accusations of mismanagement. Many people believe that federal agencies negotiate “sweetheart deals” with private business interests and environmentalists that short-change the public, and that have led to environmental problems and restricted access by the average citizen. It is apparent that many of these concerns have a basis in fact, but is my opinion that it would be better to fix the problems at the administrative level where they happen, rather than for the federal government to divest control to state and local governments that lack the infrastructure to manage these lands effectively. I have experience in managing programs at the state and county level, and I can testify that these levels of government are even more susceptible to pressure from big business, special interest groups, and ill-informed local public opinion than the federal government is.
Urbanization has served to separate our people from the outdoor experience provided by our public lands. Most of our public land is located in remote, rural areas that lie to the West of North and South Dakota, Nebraska, Kansas, Oklahoma, and Texas. Therefore, like many other political issues, the ownership and use of public lands impact the Mountain West more than urban areas. For instance, in 2018:
· In Alaska, 222.7 million acres, or 60.9% of all land is publicly owned, whereas in Nevada 56.3 million acres, or 80.1% of all land is publicly owned. Consequently, even though the number of acres is greater in Alaska, the proportion of all land that is publicly owned is greater in Nevada.
· In Idaho, 32.8 million acres, or 61.9% of all land is public. However,in New Jersey only 172 thousand acres, or 3.6% of all land is public.
· This also holds true when we compare Oregon’s 32.2 million acres of public land, or 52.3% of all lands with Indiana’s 384.7 thousand acres of public land, or 1.7% of all land.[6]
Public land is managed in diverse ways. One of the most important ways is lands that are designated as Wilderness Areas. Enacted in 1964, the Wilderness Act established the Wilderness Protection System. In 1968, Congress expanded the system. “As of July 6, 2022, there are 803 wilderness areas, totaling approximately 112 million acres, in 44 states and Puerto Rico.” About 111,695,310 acres of US Public Land has been designated as wilderness.[7]
Wilderness areas are managed to preserve some public lands
in a wild and natural state. No
vehicular traffic is allowed. Roads and
structures are forbidden. Access is
limited to foot or on horseback. In some
Wilderness Areas exceptions are made to allow use by handicapped persons. These places are kept pristine so that the
public can have access to a wilderness experience now and in the future. For a state by state listing of the acreage
and proportion of lands designated as Wilderness Areas please see: https://wilderness.net/practitioners/wilderness-search-tools/summary-reports/acreage-by-state.php
These figures may change slightly every year depending on how much land is acquired or sold. Please be careful when researching this subject on the Internet because some websites have been compromised.
My apologies for boring you with so much data. It was necessary to present the “big picture.” Here’s the point. US Public lands are, in my opinion, the property of the American people, but held in trust by the government to be managed in the public interest.
It is difficult to understand things that are not part of our personal experience. Therefore, people who have not had the benefit of experiencing the outdoors may not understand why some of us want to make a fuss about the current movement to give the management of federal public lands over to the states. It is difficult to explain, but maybe the poet Robert Service said it best:
(excerpts from) The Spell of the Yukon
By Robert Service
No! There’s the land. (Have you seen it?)
It’s the cussedest
land that I know,
From the big, dizzy
mountains that screen it
To the deep,
deathlike valleys below.
Some say God was
tired when He made it;
Some say it’s a fine
land to shun;
Maybe; but there’s
some as would trade it
For no land on
earth—and I’m one…
I’ve stood in some
mighty-mouthed hollow
That’s plumb-full of
hush to the brim;
I’ve watched the big,
husky sun wallow
In crimson and gold,
and grow dim,
Till the moon set the
pearly peaks gleaming,
And the stars tumbled
out, neck and crop;
And I’ve thought that
I surely was dreaming,
With the peace o’ the
world piled on top.
The summer—no sweeter was ever;
The sunshiny woods
all athrill;
The grayling aleap in
the river,
The bighorn asleep on
the hill.
The strong life that
never knows harness;
The wilds where the
caribou call;
The freshness, the
freedom, the farness—
O God! how I’m stuck
on it all.
The winter! the
brightness that blinds you,
The white land locked
tight as a drum,
The cold fear that
follows and finds you,
The silence that
bludgeons you dumb.
The snows that are
older than history,
The woods where the
weird shadows slant;
The stillness, the
moonlight, the mystery,
I’ve bade ’em
good-by—but I can’t.
There’s a land where
the mountains are nameless,
And the rivers all
run God knows where;
There are lives that
are erring and aimless,
And deaths that just
hang by a hair;
There are hardships
that nobody reckons;
There are valleys
unpeopled and still;
There’s a land—oh, it beckons and beckons,
And I want to go
back—and I will …
It’s the great, big,
broad land ’way up yonder,
It’s
the forests where silence has lease;
It’s the beauty that
thrills me with wonder,
It’s
the stillness that fills me with peace. [8]
Friends, please read between the lines. Do you hear the love?
Service was writing about the Yukon, but the sentiment is transferrable to the outdoor experience that is available to every American. It is spiritual. It refreshes the soul, renews the spirit, and clears the mind. I feel closer to God when I am standing on the seashore or deep in the mountain fastness.
Land Grab
Some in the government think of our public lands as a bank account. To them, it is a source of revenue that, if sold, can provide money to fund government operations. They say they would like to cut the federal expenditures driven by the management of federal public lands.
It is a lie. They will waste it. Haven’t they robbed our children’s piggy bank enough by creating an almost $40 trillion national debt? Our children’s-children’s-children will be saddled with it. Don’t they have any shame? Teddy Roosevelt must be turning over in his grave. Our public lands are our heritage. They were passed down to us by those who have gone before. It is our duty to pass them down intact to those who will follow after us.
If the federal government gives the administration of federal lands to the states, they will be transferring the cost to the states. The states do not have the human or financial resources to the handle it. The states will also lose the revenue they get from the feds in lieu of property taxes. They will have to lease or sell the land to big moneyed private interests to stay solvent. In turn, these interests will exploit the natural resources that rightly belong to the people and lay waste to the environment. How do I know … because they have done it in the past. Repeatedly.
Public access will be lost to the people. How do I know … because that is what happens when public lands are leased today. Whether the provisions of the lease provide for it or not, the lease holders treat the land as theirs, and they run our people off land that rightfully belongs to them to recreate on. Don’t try to tell me that it doesn’t happen, because it has happened to me.
This is not a “make or break” issue when choosing candidates to vote for, but it is a tipping point if all other things are equal. Please be an advocate for the responsible management of our public lands; in the public interest. Let your sitting elected officials know that you expect them to act in the best interests of the people. Make the candidates for public office aware that you will be taking their position on this issue into consideration when you vote.
Lastly, if you haven’t visited our public lands, give it a
try. You will be blessed when you experience
God’s wonderful creation.